Manchester, leading the Northern revival (pt1)

Tags

, ,

Earlier this week I took advantage of the glorious weather & spent a couple of days shooting pictures in Manchester. What I saw on my travels made me realise what a vibrant & expanding place the city has become.

I first got to know Manchester back in the 1970s when it was a city in decline. The old industries were dying & the city centre reflected that. The place has been on the up since the late 1990s but the pace of change seems to have reached new heights. The amount of new building in the city is astonishing, not just in Manchester itself, but in Salford too.

One of the places I visited was the area around Salford central station. Redevelopment in the area has opened up new opportunities to get shots of the railway passing through the city. I’d been eyeing up construction of a multi-storey car park adjacent to the station. As it had opened I took the chance to see what views were available from the top floor & I was pleasantly surprised with the results. As I took in the views I realised just how much the city skyline has changed in the last decade. New buildings have appeared in all directions, especially towards the city centre. A few years ago the former railway goods yards around Salford central station were given over to car parks. Now those car parks are being built on as millions of pounds are invested in the area. This article from the Manchester Evening News describes what’s happening. Here’s a selection of shots taken from the roof of the car park.

The approaches to Salford Central from the East,looking towards Manchester Victoria. Northern's 319386 approaches with a service to Liverpool Lime St running on the newly electrified route via the original Liverpool & Manchester railway.

The approaches to Salford Central from the East,looking towards Manchester Victoria. Northern’s 319386 approaches with a service to Liverpool Lime St running on the newly electrified route via the original Liverpool & Manchester railway.

319371 is checked at signals adjacent to Salford Central station as it heads for Manchester Victoria. The city's changing skyline is evident in the picture.

319371 is checked at signals adjacent to Salford Central station as it heads for Manchester Victoria. The city’s changing skyline is evident in the picture.

60074 passes Salford West Junction with 6H43 the 11.10 Pendleton to Tunstead empty stone train.

60074 passes Salford West Junction with 6H43 the 11.10 Pendleton to Tunstead empty stone train.

Not all the land around has been redeveloped yet though, looking eastwards from the car park across the Ordsall viaduct there’s a large tract of derelict land where the Manchester Bolton & Bury canal basin resides. You can see it in this picture;

DG215617. 319363. Ordsall viaduct. 11.6.15

The area’s set for further change once construction of the Ordsall curve gets underway. This will be a new viaduct creating a triangular junction to allow trains from Manchester Victoria to run through to Manchester Piccadilly. You can find the details here.

The new line will cut across the dual carriageway & car parks shown in the foreground of this picture, before crossing the River Irwell on a viaduct.

DG215612

Leaving the car park I strolled along Quay Street where more reconstruction is taking place. Quay House, an old 8 story office block is being torn down as part of the Spinningfields redevelopment site

Out with the old & in with the new...

Out with the old & in with the new…

The remains of Quay House...

The remains of Quay House…

Just across the road from all the new building is the Castlefield conservation area – one of my favourite bits of the city. It’s a fascinating mix of eras that stretches right back to Roman times. There’s a rich mix of architecture & industrial archaeology. The area contains the world oldest railway station (Liverpool Rd, which is now a museum) as well as some superb bridges. Castlefield is criss-crossed by railways & canals which make a fantastic setting for pubs & restaurants which have sprung up in former warehouses & factories. Needless to say it’s also a great area for photography. Here’s a selection of shots from the area.

There's a plethora of plaques in Castlefield. This one celebrates the areas links with education & chemistry.

There’s a plethora of plaques in Castlefield. This one celebrates the areas links with education & chemistry.

This plaque celebrates less settled times when the area was a battlefield in the English civil war.

This plaque celebrates less settled times when the area was a battlefield in the English civil war.

Contrasts in Castlefield. The Rochdale canal and Manchester's tallest building, BeethamTower

Contrasts in Castlefield. The Rochdale canal and Manchester’s tallest building, BeethamTower

Grocers warehouse, the birthplace of the industrial revolution in Manchester

Grocers warehouse, the birthplace of the industrial revolution in Manchester

The changing face of freight traffic in Manchester. An intermodal train bound for Trafford Park passes the canals that kickstarted the industrial revolution

The changing face of freight traffic in Manchester. An intermodal train bound for Trafford Park passes the canals that kickstarted the industrial revolution

Leaving Castlefield behind I headed across to the old Manchester Central station to take a look at the expansion of Manchester metrolink. I’ll describe what I found in part 2.

Richard Wellings caught out making it up again…

Tags

, ,

Those opposed to hs2 form the usual right wing rag-bag of folks who are opposed to public spending, so it’s no surprise to find both the Taxpayers Alliance and the Institute of Economic Affairs amongst their numbers.

Prominent amongst them is Richard Wellings, the Deputy Editorial Director of the IEA. Wellings likes to pass himself off as a transport expert (solely on the basis of the fact he got a PhD in transport, his practical experience is zilch). Wellings also likes making things up – especially numbers. It was he who invented the ‘Hs2 will cost £80bn’ claim. He did this out by totting up costs of projects that have nothing to do with Hs2 (like Crossrail 2) and inventing railway projects no-one is actually planning to build (Hs2 to Liverpool).

These nonsensical figures play well in sections of the media but anyone with genuine analytical skills & transport knowledge (or even economics) knows what a load of old tosh they really are.

But Wellings has a problem. He has form for making up ridiculous claims for the cost of rail projects – and one of those claims is coming back to haunt him, which is making him very sensitive.

Back in 2008 he wrote a blog for the IEA in which he claimed Crossrail would cost between £20-30bn. Like his hs2 figure it’s a complete fantasy. Even a fag packet would resent having such calculations written on it. You can find it here

Here’s a copy of the claim;

Wellings

It’s worth noting that this blog shows how crap Wellings is at predicting anything. Look at his comment about an interest rate rise!

Wellings big problem is that not only was Crossrail not cancelled, its also stayed well within the budget set for it. The project is 65% complete and all the (risky) tunneling is over. The bill is expected to remain well within the projected £14.8bn. That makes Wellings out by between £5.2bn to £15.2bn. That’s some fag packet!

So Welllings is starting to sweat. His credibility (never high) is on the line here.

He still insists on jumping in with both feet to the Hs2 debate on Twitter and today I challenged him on these figures. His response? He pretended he’d never made any such cost projections!

Wellings costs

Not only is the man no good with figures, he’s no good with the truth either…

Crazy anti Hs2 campaigner of the week – No 5…

Tags

, , ,

Well, not so much crazy as an outrageous liar really. Meet ‘Outoftweet123’;

Out of tweet

Yes, like most of his ilk, he prefers anonymity. He claims that Trans-Pennine electrification has been ‘scrapped’ to pay for Hs2 & uses a MEN article as ‘proof’. Here’s a link to the MEN article. Note that it doesn’t claim the work is cancelled, merely delayed. How anyone can claim its been ‘cancelled’ & expect anyone with even half a brain to fall for it is beyond me but the anti Hs2 mobs media campaign is increasingly losing the plot as more & more folk are seeing the light & abandoning them. All they have left is the serial ranters & ravers which only damages their credibility even further.

Needless to say, this abject nonsense gets retweeted by some of their other anonymous fruitloops (although there is one person in the list who really should know better).

Will any of this Stop Hs2? Of course not. But it does provide more evidence of how far out of touch with reality their campaign has become. If they had a theme tune, perhaps it should be this..

And yes – the muppets do seem very appropriate!

2023 Update.

Like most anti HS2 tweets, this one really hasn’t aged well. In 2023 the Trans-Pennine route upgrade (TRU) is in full-swing. Now (3rd April) work to upgrade and electrify the route at Stalybridge is in its last few days after a long blockade. Meanwhile, work continues on the line from Huddersfield to Leeds with work compounds established and even whole stations being moved (such as the one at Morley). Cancelled my arse!

I’ve a small favour to ask…
If you enjoy reading this or any of the other blogs I’ve written, please click on an advert or two. You don’t have to buy anything you don’t want to of course – although if you did find something that tickled your fancy that would be fab! – but the revenue from them helps me to cover some of the cost of maintaining this site (which isn’t cheap and comes out of my own pocket). Remember, 99% of the pictures used in my blogs can be purchased as prints from my other website –  https://paulbigland.zenfolio.com/

Or – you can now buy me a coffee! https://ko-fi.com/paulbigland68312

Thank you!

Hs2 Ltd respond to the Petitioning Committees first report

Tags

, , ,

On the 26th March the Hs2 Petitioning Bill Committee published its first interim report which contained a series of requests & observations generated by the petitioning process. You can find their report here.

Yesterday Hs2 Ltd published their response, which you can read here.

Both make interesting as they give an insight into the issues raised & the vast amount of detailed work that’s gone into progress so far. One thing in particular caught my eye, which was these comments regarding ‘template’ petitions;

Petitions

Cut & paste petitions were a centrepiece of the anti Hs2 mobs tactics. They hoped that, if they swamped the Committee with petitions they could bog down the whole process & delay Hs2 long enough that a new Government would decide to cancel the project due to delays & costs. Like all the other anti Hs2 tactics, it’s failed. The Petitioning Committee have made it clear they aren’t going to let themselves get bogged down this way & neither are Hs2 Ltd.

Another interesting aspect of the Petitioning Committee’s report is that they are looking to make recommendations on the conduct & process of future Hybrid Bills (such as the Phase 2 bill). What’s the bet that one of those recommendations will be to close the loophole of ‘template’ petitions & prevent the threat of future bills getting bogged down in this fashion?

Chaos across the Pennines

Tags

, , ,

At 8.15 am a tragic accident on the M62 which involved 3 lorries closed the motorway in both directions at Milnrow in Lancashire. Sadly,one driver is seriously injured. This has caused chaos on both sides of the Pennines. Here in Sowerby Bridge we always know when there’s problems on this section of the M62 as all the roads through the town & surrounding area become clogged with vehicles trying to find alternative routes.

Today’s accident was a bad one. The M62 has been closed all day. Late in the afternoon the Eastbound side was opened but the level of traffic is far below what the motorway normally carries – as you can see from the pictures I took at Scammonden at 21:05 this evening.

The M62 at Scammonden looking East this evening

The M62 at Scammonden looking East this evening.The Westbound side of the motorway remains closed

Looking West at the same location

Looking West at the same location

Meanwhile, high above the M62, diverted traffic was nose to tail on the A640. Clearly, many lorry drivers had run out of hours & had parked up wherever they could find space. Those with empty trailers left their back doors open to show would be thieves there was nothing worth stealing. The scenes reminded me of images of an army retreating in disarray after a crushing defeat. I swapped words with one or two of the drivers who didn’t know the area & wanted to know where they might park up or how far it was to the nearest pub. I couldn’t help but feel sorry for all these people, crawling along an A road at 10mph at best with no idea where they were or how long it would take them to get home.

The queues and parked up lorries reminded me of a retreating army...

The queues and parked up lorries reminded me of a retreating army…

Take the long way home...

Take the long way home…

Today’s problems bring highlight the strategic importance of the M62 & the lack of viable alternatives. I’d hope the Governments commitment to the ‘Northern Powerhouse’ & development of better Trans-Pennine rail links will help shift traffic away from motorways like the M62 & see more freight transfer from road to rail.

There and back again…

Tags

, , ,

I’m back in the bosom of the Pennines for the weekend after a few days on the English Riviera helping the folks from ACoRP with preparations for their community rail awards which will be held in Torquay in October.

I must admit to being pleasantly surprised by Torquay. Despite having a reputation as a destination for the elderly there’s a lot of life in the town – and if the floating gin palaces in the harbour are anything to go by there’s a fair bit of money too! The ACoRP awards will be held in the Riviera International Centre which is by the sea front & adjacent to the lovely Torre Abbey. The centre’s exterior isn’t up to much as it betrays its age & that eras love of bare concrete. Inside is a different story & the facilities we checked out make it ideal for the awards. The staff were very helpful & easy conversationalists, regaling us with stories of previous events & what happens when several thousand young farmers descend on the resort for a gathering at the centre!

I was only needed for some of the meetings so I had time to nip out & get pictures at Torquay’s attractive railway station which dates from 1878. Unlike many stations of the era it’s intact & boasts full length canopies on both the Up & Down platforms. Both the canopies and the footbridge have been listed Grade 2. The station is staffed & still possesses both a ticket office and cafe. Right now the buildings are being refurbished, the attractive old footbridge has been closed & passengers are using a temporary structure until May when all the work will be completed. Torquay isn’t the only station on the route receiving attention as both Torre & Paignton are being refurbished at the same time.

Torquay is served by both First Great Western and Cross Country trains so you get to see both ends of the spectrum when it comes to trains running the services.Local services are in the hands of 2 -car Class 143 Pacers which are strengthened to 3 cars by the addition of a class 153. You’ll also see 2-car Class 150s, some of which are old friends of mine as previously they were used on the Gospel Oak- Barking line in London. Intercity services are in the hands of the venerable HST whilst Cross Country use a mix of 4 & 5 car Voyagers.

The Up (London) side buildings at Torquay

The Up (London) side buildings at Torquay

The temporary footbridge with the main station buildings beyond.

The temporary footbridge with the main station buildings beyond.

After our meetings we had time to explore the cliff trails to nearby Babbacombe which form part of the South West Coast path. The weather was glorious & the views across Lyme Bay were at their best. Here’s an example.

DG215228. Cliffs.Torquay. 3.6.15

Of course when we reached Babbacome we had to take a trip on the funicular railway down to Oddicombe beach.The 720ft long 5ft 8in gauge railway opened in 1926 but was closed during the war for security reasons & didn’t reopen until 1951. It’s a true community railway as ownership was transferred from Torbay Borough Council to the Babbacombe Cliff Railway Community Interest Company in 2009. You can find their website here.

DG215302. Babbacombe funicular railway. 4.6.15

The red sandstone cliffs around the bay are high, steep and unstable. The North end of Oddicombe beach is buried under a rather frightening looking cliff collapse that carried away a house from the end of the cul de sac 150 ft above back in 2013. Incredibly, despite the obviously dangerous condition of the landslide & the warning signs on the beach some people ignore them to risk both their own lives & those of their children to frolic under the nose of the collapse.

What bit of 'danger' don't people understand?

What bit of ‘danger’ don’t people understand?

Our brief chance to mix business with pleasure came to an end on Friday but it was very worthwhile trip. Now we’re all looking forward returning for the awards on October 1st. So,if you’d like the opportunity to join us all – now’s your chance. The closing date for entries to the ACoRP Community Rail awards is the 19th June. Here’s a link to the Awards webpage where you can download an entry form or book a table at the event.

Latest rail passenger growth: The news just gets worse & worse for the anti Hs2 mob…

Tags

,

Yesterday the ORR released the latest rail passenger statistics and (yet again) the numbers hit new records.

The statistics relate to Quarter 4 (1 January 2015 to 31 March 2015) & show that over 1.6 billion passenger journeys were made, the highest recorded figure since the series of statistics began in 2002-03. In fact, passenger growth has been continuous for every year (bar 1) since 1992, as this chart shows.

Hs2 graph

Mind you, the chart also exposes another of the anti Hs2 campaigns claims – that the internet, home working & teleconferencing et al will make Hs2 redundant.

Looking at the latest figures in detail it’s clear that passenger growth is across the board. What’s interesting is the way that both Long Distance (LD) and regional services are growing faster than London & the South East. Long Distance growth is the area Hs2 antis always try & focus on to the exclusion of all else, so the figures for LD will particularly hurt them.

LD & regional

Remember that 5.8% is 3.8% higher than the 2% growth projections used to justify the Hs2 business case. What’s also significant is the very strong regional growth of 6.1% which is the largest quarters growth ever recorded by these stats.

Those regional services use many of the major hub stations like Leeds, Manchester Piccadilly, Birmingham New St & Sheffield that Hs2 will free up capacity at. If we want to grow regional services we’re going to need to add capacity to them – which is exactly what Hs2 does.

Another sector that has registered very strong growth (9%) is the long-distance open access operators like Grand Central & Hull Trains.

Open access

OA operators often struggle to get paths due to a lack of capacity on the East & West coast main lines. Yet clearly, there’s a demand for their services. There’s an obvious argument to allow them to grow (at little risk to the public purse) but there’s little chance of this happening without Hs2 creating capacity.

Contrast these record passenger numbers with the utterly bonkers beliefs of Hs2 antis – like this..

Docorb

Meanwhile, on another front, let’s have a look at how UK passenger growth compares with the rest of the EU.

EU comparson.

And..

EU comparison 2

Clearly, the majority of EU countries would give their eye teeth for the level of growth that’s being experienced in the UK!

Finally, let’s have a look at some long-term trends. This is a chart showing the growth in passenger Kms (The number of kilometres traveled by passengers on the network) across all sectors between 2002 & the present day.

Pax Km

From this it’s clear that not only has growth been continuous, but that it’s also accelerating.

Despite all the evidence some still try & pretend we don’t need High Speed 2s capacity for the future. Is it any wonder their campaign has failed?

UPDATE:

Within a few minutes of the blog appearing, Bury based PR Nigel Sarbutts has responded on Twitter to provide a wonderful example of both the levels of intellectual bankruptcy & self delusion of the anti Hs2 campaign – not to mention why the world of PR has a reputation for a very uneasy relationship with truthfulness!

His tweets?

Sarbutts

The claim that fluctuations between quarters in a year is actually a ‘fall’ is as intellectually bankrupt as you can get. Not to mention that fact they’re all still growth one only has to look at the yearly averages for the following years and it’s blindingly obvious that the growth in passenger KMs is accelerating

2011-12. Average 4.7
2012-13. Average 4.87
2013-14. Average 4.92
2014-15. Average 5.2

But not to an anti in denial of course!

Sarbutts 2

Still, I should thank Sarbutts for handing me such a fine example of the anti Hs2 campaigns deceit & denial on a plate. Look how he’s changed the wording on his later claims..

sarbutts lies 2

One would expect that a genuine professional & person of integrity would be ashamed to be caught so blatantly twisting the truth. Draw your own conclusions that they’re not…

This week’s most bonkers anti Hs2 mob message- No 4.

Tags

, ,

The combination of Hs2 and crazy UKIP supporters has always been a powerful one but the parties abject humiliation in the general election has meant most crazy kippers have crawled back under their rocks. However, today one has thrown their tinfoil hat away and tweeted this gem!

Bonkers

As this one shows, Kippers have never let facts get in the way of their crazy EU paranoia. The ability to deliberately misunderstand what an EU Directive really is isn’t unusual in their world. Unluckily for them the UK electorate saw through them & halved the number of MPs they have.

Hopefully, the party will have disappeared through a combination of internecine warfare and the attentions of the Grim Reaper* by the next election.

*The Grim Reaper should be the party’s logo due to the fact their age demographic is mostly on the wrong side of 65…

My reply to a question from Surveyor Magazine

Tags

Yesterday, Surveyor magazine asked if Transport Minister Patrick McLoughlin was right in his assertion that the argument over Hs2 had been won. This was my reply.

He’s absolutely right – and here’s why..

Let’s deal with a few political realities, shall we? The general election exposed the anti hs2 camp as toothless. They have no political clout & their ‘no votes for you with Hs2’ campaign failed to deliver them any political influence whatsoever – even in their supposed heartlands of the Chilterns & Warks. The cold, hard fact is – when it comes to voting for their MP, people have far wider concerns than HS2. The anti Hs2 campaign is in complete denial of this political reality & takes refuge in opinion polls. Their problem is – opinion polls don’t elect politicians, voters do!

In the context of real political power, opinion polls are meaningless. The antis can claim 88% (or whatever) ‘oppose’ Hs2 because they grumble about it in an opinion poll, but if that doesn’t translate into votes – it’s worthless.

Back in the real world, we’ve had a party that made it crystal clear that it was going to press ahead with Hs2 if it was returned to Government. Complaints that there was no ‘real debate’ about Hs2 are simply sour grapes from supporters of a campaign that was never going to win. The anti Hs2 campaign hoped UKIP would be the cavalry that would ride to their rescue but that was never going to happen.

So, McLoughlin is right. The argument has been won. There’s no credible opposition to Hs2, there’s simply a dwindling number of folks who complain about it but who can’t stop it.

In the next 18 months this number will shrink even more as the Hs2 petitioning process is settled and more people are compensated for genuine losses. By the end of 2016 the Hs2 Hybrid Bill will receive Royal Assent & construction will start in 2017 (although enabling works will start in 2016). That means, by the time of the next election, Phase 1 will have been under construction for nearly 4 years & the phase 2 Hybrid Bill will have begun its course through Parliament.

With that in mind, does anyone seriously believe that UKIP (if they haven’t disappeared in internecine warfare) will still oppose Hs2? Or even the Greens – bearing in mind there’s many Greens who are unhappy with the parties stance on hs2 & want to change it?

Labour remain staunchly behind hs2 & will continue that way as it brings undeniable benefits to their remaining heartlands – the major cities & the old industrial areas of the Midlands, NW & NE.

So, who will stop hs2? There’s no-one. The argument is over. Now it’s time to get on with the job of building it – just as McLoughlin has said…

I’m moving office..

Tags

– well, for a few days at least. I’m currently sat on an Exeter bound Cross-Country Voyager ex-Manchester Manchester. I’m part of the Association of Community Rail Partnerships team heading down to Torquay to arrange the details of their annual community rail awards which will be held in the town on October 1st. Entries for the awards are still open, so if you want details you can download an entry form from the ACoRP website, which is here.

We’ll be down in Torquay for a couple of days so expect some pictures and even a blog or two if I have the time.

After the gale force winds & torrential rain we’ve been treated to in the Pennines these past few days I’m looking forward to some pleasant evenings & balmy weather on the English Riviera.