Latest rail passenger growth: The news just gets worse & worse for the anti Hs2 mob…

Tags

,

Yesterday the ORR released the latest rail passenger statistics and (yet again) the numbers hit new records.

The statistics relate to Quarter 4 (1 January 2015 to 31 March 2015) & show that over 1.6 billion passenger journeys were made, the highest recorded figure since the series of statistics began in 2002-03. In fact, passenger growth has been continuous for every year (bar 1) since 1992, as this chart shows.

Hs2 graph

Mind you, the chart also exposes another of the anti Hs2 campaigns claims – that the internet, home working & teleconferencing et al will make Hs2 redundant.

Looking at the latest figures in detail it’s clear that passenger growth is across the board. What’s interesting is the way that both Long Distance (LD) and regional services are growing faster than London & the South East. Long Distance growth is the area Hs2 antis always try & focus on to the exclusion of all else, so the figures for LD will particularly hurt them.

LD & regional

Remember that 5.8% is 3.8% higher than the 2% growth projections used to justify the Hs2 business case. What’s also significant is the very strong regional growth of 6.1% which is the largest quarters growth ever recorded by these stats.

Those regional services use many of the major hub stations like Leeds, Manchester Piccadilly, Birmingham New St & Sheffield that Hs2 will free up capacity at. If we want to grow regional services we’re going to need to add capacity to them – which is exactly what Hs2 does.

Another sector that has registered very strong growth (9%) is the long-distance open access operators like Grand Central & Hull Trains.

Open access

OA operators often struggle to get paths due to a lack of capacity on the East & West coast main lines. Yet clearly, there’s a demand for their services. There’s an obvious argument to allow them to grow (at little risk to the public purse) but there’s little chance of this happening without Hs2 creating capacity.

Contrast these record passenger numbers with the utterly bonkers beliefs of Hs2 antis – like this..

Docorb

Meanwhile, on another front, let’s have a look at how UK passenger growth compares with the rest of the EU.

EU comparson.

And..

EU comparison 2

Clearly, the majority of EU countries would give their eye teeth for the level of growth that’s being experienced in the UK!

Finally, let’s have a look at some long-term trends. This is a chart showing the growth in passenger Kms (The number of kilometres traveled by passengers on the network) across all sectors between 2002 & the present day.

Pax Km

From this it’s clear that not only has growth been continuous, but that it’s also accelerating.

Despite all the evidence some still try & pretend we don’t need High Speed 2s capacity for the future. Is it any wonder their campaign has failed?

UPDATE:

Within a few minutes of the blog appearing, Bury based PR Nigel Sarbutts has responded on Twitter to provide a wonderful example of both the levels of intellectual bankruptcy & self delusion of the anti Hs2 campaign – not to mention why the world of PR has a reputation for a very uneasy relationship with truthfulness!

His tweets?

Sarbutts

The claim that fluctuations between quarters in a year is actually a ‘fall’ is as intellectually bankrupt as you can get. Not to mention that fact they’re all still growth one only has to look at the yearly averages for the following years and it’s blindingly obvious that the growth in passenger KMs is accelerating

2011-12. Average 4.7
2012-13. Average 4.87
2013-14. Average 4.92
2014-15. Average 5.2

But not to an anti in denial of course!

Sarbutts 2

Still, I should thank Sarbutts for handing me such a fine example of the anti Hs2 campaigns deceit & denial on a plate. Look how he’s changed the wording on his later claims..

sarbutts lies 2

One would expect that a genuine professional & person of integrity would be ashamed to be caught so blatantly twisting the truth. Draw your own conclusions that they’re not…

This week’s most bonkers anti Hs2 mob message- No 4.

Tags

, ,

The combination of Hs2 and crazy UKIP supporters has always been a powerful one but the parties abject humiliation in the general election has meant most crazy kippers have crawled back under their rocks. However, today one has thrown their tinfoil hat away and tweeted this gem!

Bonkers

As this one shows, Kippers have never let facts get in the way of their crazy EU paranoia. The ability to deliberately misunderstand what an EU Directive really is isn’t unusual in their world. Unluckily for them the UK electorate saw through them & halved the number of MPs they have.

Hopefully, the party will have disappeared through a combination of internecine warfare and the attentions of the Grim Reaper* by the next election.

*The Grim Reaper should be the party’s logo due to the fact their age demographic is mostly on the wrong side of 65…

My reply to a question from Surveyor Magazine

Tags

Yesterday, Surveyor magazine asked if Transport Minister Patrick McLoughlin was right in his assertion that the argument over Hs2 had been won. This was my reply.

He’s absolutely right – and here’s why..

Let’s deal with a few political realities, shall we? The general election exposed the anti hs2 camp as toothless. They have no political clout & their ‘no votes for you with Hs2’ campaign failed to deliver them any political influence whatsoever – even in their supposed heartlands of the Chilterns & Warks. The cold, hard fact is – when it comes to voting for their MP, people have far wider concerns than HS2. The anti Hs2 campaign is in complete denial of this political reality & takes refuge in opinion polls. Their problem is – opinion polls don’t elect politicians, voters do!

In the context of real political power, opinion polls are meaningless. The antis can claim 88% (or whatever) ‘oppose’ Hs2 because they grumble about it in an opinion poll, but if that doesn’t translate into votes – it’s worthless.

Back in the real world, we’ve had a party that made it crystal clear that it was going to press ahead with Hs2 if it was returned to Government. Complaints that there was no ‘real debate’ about Hs2 are simply sour grapes from supporters of a campaign that was never going to win. The anti Hs2 campaign hoped UKIP would be the cavalry that would ride to their rescue but that was never going to happen.

So, McLoughlin is right. The argument has been won. There’s no credible opposition to Hs2, there’s simply a dwindling number of folks who complain about it but who can’t stop it.

In the next 18 months this number will shrink even more as the Hs2 petitioning process is settled and more people are compensated for genuine losses. By the end of 2016 the Hs2 Hybrid Bill will receive Royal Assent & construction will start in 2017 (although enabling works will start in 2016). That means, by the time of the next election, Phase 1 will have been under construction for nearly 4 years & the phase 2 Hybrid Bill will have begun its course through Parliament.

With that in mind, does anyone seriously believe that UKIP (if they haven’t disappeared in internecine warfare) will still oppose Hs2? Or even the Greens – bearing in mind there’s many Greens who are unhappy with the parties stance on hs2 & want to change it?

Labour remain staunchly behind hs2 & will continue that way as it brings undeniable benefits to their remaining heartlands – the major cities & the old industrial areas of the Midlands, NW & NE.

So, who will stop hs2? There’s no-one. The argument is over. Now it’s time to get on with the job of building it – just as McLoughlin has said…

I’m moving office..

Tags

– well, for a few days at least. I’m currently sat on an Exeter bound Cross-Country Voyager ex-Manchester Manchester. I’m part of the Association of Community Rail Partnerships team heading down to Torquay to arrange the details of their annual community rail awards which will be held in the town on October 1st. Entries for the awards are still open, so if you want details you can download an entry form from the ACoRP website, which is here.

We’ll be down in Torquay for a couple of days so expect some pictures and even a blog or two if I have the time.

After the gale force winds & torrential rain we’ve been treated to in the Pennines these past few days I’m looking forward to some pleasant evenings & balmy weather on the English Riviera.

Anti campaigners claims that Hs2 won’t ‘rebalance the North’ are dealt another body blow.

Tags

, , ,

The anti Hs2 campaign’s claims that Hs2 will do nothing to help rebalance the economy & help the North were dealt another serious blow today when Manchester airport announced a £1bn expansion plan that is expected to more than double the number of passengers from 23m to 55m by 2050 and create an extra 20,000 jobs at the airport.

Construction Enquirer reports on the plans here:

Manchester Airport rolls out £1bn expansion plan

Plus, there’s more from the Manchester Evening News here:

http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/manchester-airport-expansion-plan-security-9370929

CE reports that “The dramatic expansion scheme has been prompted by the second phase of HS2 and the Government’s plan to improve east-west rail connections of HS3 as part of the development of a Northern Powerhouse.”

This is good news for the North. It also weakens the case for a third runway in the South-East at either Gatwick or Heathrow as Hs2 will provide a fast connection between Manchester airport and many cities (including London). For example:

Manchester Airport – Birmingham will be cut from 1hr 44 to just 32mins

Manchester Airport – London will be cut from 2hr 24 to just 1hr 03 (quicker than getting to Heathrow on the tube!)

Manchester Airport – Heathrow will be cut from 3hr 24 to just 1hr 18.

In addition, the plans for Hs3 should bring many of the North’s cities within 30mins travelling time from Manchester airport, creating a true regional hub. At the moment many folks (like me) still find it more convenient to travel to Heathrow to catch certain flights. Manchester’s expansion plans should cut this need and also reduce the number of internal connecting flights to/from Heathrow.

Joe Rukin & Stop Hs2 are living on another planet.

Tags

, , ,

If evidence were needed that the anti Hs2 campaign has completely lost the plot then look no further than this piece of self serving nonsense from Joe Rukin published in today’s Bucks Herald.

http://www.bucksherald.co.uk/news/more-news/hs2-reasons-to-be-cheerful-following-election-1-6772919

Headlined ‘reasons to be cheerful’ it’s straight from the Comical Ali school of reality denial & wishful thinking. It’s no co-incidence this daft piece of propaganda appears in local rag the Bucks Herald. The Herald is a semi-official mouthpiece of the anti Hs2 campaign that’s happy to churn out any old rubbish the antis feed it (hardly surprising then, that its circulation is diving).

What’s particularly sad about Rukin’s desperate attempt to save his own neck & non-job is that some poor folks affected by Hs2 may well be given false hope by this breathtaking piece of reality denial masquerading as informed comment. Although, what’s interesting is -if you read behind the lines, Rukin is tacitly admitting that there’s nothing they can do to Stop Hs2, they’re simply praying someone else will. Mind you, before the election they though UKIP would be the cavalry riding to their rescue – and look where that got them…

Meanwhile, what are the likes of Stophs2 actually doing? Nothing. They’ve no events planned at all. No rallies or demo’s, no gatherings – nothing. They’re reduced to an internet presence that few see or care about – or the occasional uncritical article in friendly local rags like the Bucks Herald.

Meanwhile, back in the real world, the Transport Minister, Patrick McLoughlin is in Leeds today,along with Hs2 Chairman Sir David Higgins. McLoughlin will be talking not just about accelerated progress on Hs2 but also Hs3. I’ll add more on this later but you can be sure of one thing. They won’t be giving Rukin any reasons to be cheerful…

You can find McLoughlin’s bullish speech here:

https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/transport-has-power-to-change-the-north

As predicted, there’s not a single crumb of comfort for Rukin & the rest of the anti Hs2 mob. For example:

“Thankfully, the northern electorate didn’t listen to those who tried to play politics with HS2 during the election campaign.

Neither did the people of the west and east Midlands.

So the argument’s been won.

HS2 will be built.”

Or this:

“Start preparing now.

Because HS2 is coming.

It’s coming to Leeds.

To Manchester.

To south Yorkshire.

And the east Midlands.

The time to debate the various merits of high speed rail is over.

Now it’s time to get our cities ready.

Ready for construction.

Ready for investment and regeneration.”

Now, Joe, what was that about reasons to be cheerful?

Number crunching…

Tags

, ,

Following on from yesterday’s blog about the anti Hs2 campaigns false claims of ‘falling’ passenger numbers & no business case for Hs2 I’ve been crunching a few numbers.

When Virgin Trains started running trains on the West Coast Main Line (WCML) in 1997 there were 13.6 million passenger journeys. In 2014 that had increased to 34.5million – an increase of 153.6% or an average of 5.6% per year. The Hs2 business case is based on an annual growth of just 2% per year up to 2039..

We are already far, far ahead of Hs2’s conservative projections – and that’s just because of one TOC on the WCML.

According to the anti Hs2 mob, these people don't exist. (or should just get an earlier train)...

According to the anti Hs2 mob, these people don’t exist. (or should just get an earlier train)…

Yet another nail in the anti Hs2 campaigns coffin

Tags

, , ,

One of the most laughable aspects of the anti Hs2 campaign is the way antis try & pretend there’s no capacity argument for building Hs2. They do this by focusing exclusively on peak time Virgin trains services out of Euston & ignore everything else such as inter regional & local services, freight, or capacity constraints at other major stations on the routes Hs2 will relieve. These ‘look over there’ tactics fool a few observers but anyone with any knowledge or experience of the railways isn’t fooled.

A few are even stupid enough to try & pretend passenger numbers are falling. Like this one;

Docorb

Such idiotic claims fly in the face of fact – as the latest statistics from ORR (released in March 2015) so clearly show:

ORR

What’s also significant is the even larger rise in long distance passenger kilometres (The number of kilometres travelled by passengers on the network).

ORR 3

This isn’t an isolated rise either. The last ORR release for Quarter 2 noted record numbers then too:

ORR 2

Then long distance passenger Km’s rose by 5.5%

Click to access passenger-rail-usage-quality-report-2014-15-q2.pdf

Of course these are only the long distance figures. There’s sustained growth across all the other sectors too. Hs2 antis deliberately ignore them but it’s obvious they have an impact on mainline capacity as they use all the main stations that long distance services like Virgin West Coast do!

Another nail in their coffin is an interview with Virgin Trains West Coast Executive Director (Ops), Phil Bearpark which has been published in the Railway Gazette.

This mentions that Virgin have enjoyed ‘linear’ growth since the introduction of the 2007 VHF timetable. So much so that passenger journeys reached 34.5m in 2014-15. Bearpark told RG that “if numbers continue to rise at the same rate, then in 2026, when Hs2 starts, it is our intention that we’ll have got to 50 million passengers by then through year-on-year growth” In Bearpark’s words. This “was the business case for hs2”

Of course, this is just the WCML. Hs2 also releases capacity on the East Coast and Midland main lines, which are also experiencing a growth in traffic & capacity constraints.

With the economy picking up & the UK population projected to hit 70 million by 2027 (the year after Hs2 phase 1 opens ) & 73.2 million by 2035 (two years after phase 2) there’s no reason at all to believe Bearpark’s projections are optimistic . Well, not unless you’re an Hs2 anti in denial of course!

Whatever happened to…

Tags

, ,

– those fantastic pub Landlords & Landladies that used to make some alehouses such a pleasure to visit?

I’m old enough to remember the days when a pub was known by the character of the person who ran it – those individual Landlords or Landladies who made a pub their own. In those days the licensees name above the door actually meant something. I can still remember the name of the Landlady of the first pub I drank in as a teenager nearly 40 years ago – Grace Kathleen Taylor. She was replaced by a real character called Monica Brownlee. Anyone who drank in the Old Ship in Southport back in the 1980s couldn’t fail to remember Monica with her cheroots, her leather pants & those snappy one-liners delivered in an Irish brogue! Those were the days…

Nowadays you’d be hard pressed to even know who the licensees of many pubs are. Their territory’s no longer marked with their names above the door & for better or worse, many of them leave the running of the pub to bar staff & rarely grace the customers with their presence. Not that some of them have any presence to be honest…

I mention this because tonight I ventured into a pub that we used to frequent & found it a shadow of its former self. A few years ago this pub in Sowerby Bridge was a vibrant community pub. Owned by the Ossett Brewery, the place was run by landlady Linda who employed a great bunch of bar staff. That said, Linda was behind the bar herself most nights. You knew it was her establishment & she knew her regulars & what they drank – which was always a sign of a good pub.

Sadly, Linda & her partner Rob moved on & were replaced by a chap who only lasted a year or so at most. I hadn’t been in for a while but I’d bumped into some of the old regulars who told me the pub had been taken over by another new manager & it had gone downhill. The prices had gone up & the atmosphere had gone down. Last night I popped in & saw why. One harassed barman was trying to serve several people all on his own. Of the ‘landlady’ there was no sign (apparently, she hadn’t been seen all night). Finally, after the rush had died down, a young lady in slippers & semi-pajamas drifted downstairs. Without a word to anyone (including the barman) or even acknowledging their presence she emptied some bags of change into the till before disappearing back upstairs like a wraith.

Needless to say, I won’t be calling in again. If Ossett wonder why the takings at one of their pubs has taken a dive, perhaps they should look at the quality of their staff training & recruitment.

Parliament’s back to work & the HS2 Bill moves on

Tags

, , ,

Today’s Queen’s speech means Parliament is back at work & progress on the Hs2 Hybrid Bill will pick up where it left off – with a slight amendment. One of the Hybrid Bill members lost his seat at the election so a replacement will need to be found for the former Lib-Dem MP for Eastleigh, Mike Thornton. There’s speculation in some circles that his replacement will come from the SNP as they’ve replaced the Lib-Dems as the 3rd largest. We shall have to wait and see…

Continuity is also the name of the game over at the Department of Transport where Patrick McLaughlin remains in post as Transport Minister. This is good news for the rail industry and Hs2 as there’s no need to get a new Minister up to speed with what needs to be done.

Of course, all this is bad news for the anti Hs2 camp who don’t seem know which way to turn now their ‘great white hope’ (UKIP) has vanished in a cloud of voting papers – taking a huge chunk of the anti Hs2 tweeters with them. The anti Hs2 mobs Twitter campaign has descended into farce since the election. There are still a few blowhards hanging on from the old days who think ranting on the internet changes anything but many of them are isolated individuals with no backing, or what can be charitably called ‘special people’. Here’s a typical example of the isolated Tweeter from that well known hotbed of anti hs2 activism. Err, Lisburn, in Northern Ireland (‘hotbed’? Are you sure this is right? Ed).

Busker

The folks who are noticeable by their absence nowadays are the supposed ‘action group’ network although this is hardly surprising. They’ve been in decline for years & really have nowhere to go anymore. The Hybrid Bill petitioning process has drawn any sting they might have thought they had – and the election results have shown they’ve no political clout (even at a local council level). Their public rallies have been abandoned as an embarrassment as so few folks turn up. So there’s little reason for their existence any more.

I do genuinely feel sorry for the people who are affected by Hs2 & who’ve been gulled into thinking the anti campaign really could stop Hs2. They’ve been given false hope & some of them have thrown away both time & money. The election results have shown that the scales have dropped from quite a few eyes. Sadly it’s too much to hope that the people who cynically exploit them (StopHs2 & Hs2aa) will suffer an outbreak of honesty, realism or contrition. However, the good news is that as their activist base dies a source of funding dries up too. As StopHs2 funds come predominantly from one man – it’s anyone’s guess when he’ll see sense & stops throwing his money away.

As another example of a campaign going nowhere fast I’ve updated the antis ‘scores on the doors’. These show their social media growth (or not!) on Facebook & Twitter.

Hs2

The usual caveats apply. Not all followers are supporters etc…

Looking through social media the anti’s sense of aggrieved bewilderment is obvious. Some of them had bought into their own hype so completely they still can’t admit what had really happened at the election. There’s complete denial over the implications of their general election no-show & risible ‘no votes for you with Hs2’campaign (which influenced no-one at all). What none of them will talk about or deal with is the awkward question of ‘how are we going to Stop Hs2 now’? Because the answer is staring them in the face. They can’t. At the risk of falling in the trap of Godwin’s law – I can only compare them to the last days of the Third Reich & the mentality inside the bunker as the Russians closed in, with UKIP in the role of General Felix Steiner’s Army Detachment.

No doubt there’ll still be media speculation & a fair bit of froth in the next few months as the Hs2 Hybrid Bill continues its course through Parliament but the position is clear. There’s no credible opposition to Hs2 & there’s even less of a credible alternative. Rail passenger growths continues apace as the economy picks up – and look out for some interesting statistics & comments to appear from Virgin Trains on their West Coast business.