• About

Paul Bigland

~ Blogging on transport, travel & whatever takes my fancy.

Paul Bigland

Tag Archives: Houseof Lords

The Hs2 debate shows why we should abolish the House of Lords

30 Tuesday Jun 2015

Posted by Paul Bigland in House of Lords, Hs2

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Houseof Lords, Hs2

Much excitement was generated amongst those of us who follow the HS2 debate by the spectacle late last year of the House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee investigating the economic case for HS2. Or not. After seeing the Chairman, Lord Hollick, simpering over Martin Tett of Buckinghamshire County Council and the failing 51m group of local authorities, expectations of objective and informed analysis rather faded.

Even on its own subject of Economics, the Committee seemed lacking. Lord Lawson of Blaby was deeply interested in different yield management practices on air and rail, but showed no clue that the cost structures of the two modes might drive them in different directions in this respect:

• For an airline, the marginal costs of flying compared with the fixed costs of being an airline are high, so you don’t fly unless you can fill your plane, and a regular interval service means having the same flight times two days in a row.

• By contrast, for a railway, the variable costs of running a train are low compared with the fixed costs of having a railway to run on, so it’s worth running a train so long as the extra fares match those small extra costs, and a regular interval service throughout the day is a key factor in generating income. That’s been common knowledge since the Brighton line electrification in 1932 – to everyone except ex-Chancellors of the Exchequer, apparently.

Lord Lawson (that’s Nigel Lawson, famous mainly for setting off the inflation of the late 1980s by shadowing the Deutschmark until, sadly too late, told not to by the Prime Minister) then confirmed the depth and subtlety of his knowledge by repeatedly suggesting that HS2 was only being proposed so that we could boast of having the fastest trains in Europe, an allegation that depends for supporting evidence on his own imagination. And possibly on the fact that he lives mainly in France these days.

This detachment from reality was reinforced by the constant refrain that pricing can spread peaks of demand to the point of not needing extra capacity – as if most of us have any choice when we travel to work. Unsurprisingly, given this naivety on the part of Their Lordships, the very real benefit of HS2 for the commuters who will inherit the West Coast Main Line was dismissed as if it was a disadvantage of the project, instead of a measure to address growth from locations such as Leighton Buzzard, Milton Keynes and Northampton on about the only route into London where significant new housing can be accommodated.

Thank heavens for Lord Deighton, giving evidence, who declared in respect of capacity that in his experience, the more people knew about capacity, the more convinced they were that there was a capacity problem on the WCML and beyond. Cue cries of “vested interests” from the opposition!

In attempting to minimise the regeneration benefits of infrastructure projects such as HS2, the committee were clearly influenced by the Institute of Economic Affairs, who have just broken cover with a report proposing the conversion of railways into roads – something that will probably not play well in the Chilterns as of course it was the Chiltern line that was proposed, and rejected, for such a conversion back in the 1980s. The IEA attempted to dismiss regeneration benefits on the basis that Doncaster is still depressed despite having a good train service to London, but neither the IEA nor the Committee had the wit to wonder what a town whose industries were based on building wooden railway carriages and steam locomotives to pull them would now be like without a good rail service to London.

If the Committee seemed ignorant of life and the economy North of Hampstead, this was rubbed in first by Richard Wellings of the IEA (yes, that IEA) who diagnosed the problems of the North as being due to “poor human capital” – that means “people” to anyone except a think-tank – then by Lord Carrington’s suggestion that HS2 would be building a station “in the wilds of Yorkshire”. He couldn’t name this alleged station, of course, but presumably meant Meadowhall – an established transport interchange adjacent to the M1, served by three railways, a tramway and numerous bus routes, and 10 minutes by frequent trains from Sheffield Midland station. Yorkshire, happily, still has wilder wilds than that!

At other times, having summoned a variety of busy people to entertain it, the Committee didn’t seem to know who it was actually talking to and why. Michele Dix of Transport for London was closely questioned about Network Rail’s plans for the rebuilding of Euston, in which TfL no doubt have an interest, but for which they have no responsibility. The issue had simply been in the news that morning, and the Committee just asked the first person they saw. Michele Dix also made clear that TfL regarded Crossrail 2 as essential full stop regardless of HS2, and that the link with HS2 Phase 1 was purely a matter of construction programming. Probably again prompted by the discredited IEA who are determined to add the costs of Crossrail 2 to those of HS2 (but not its benefits, of course), the Committee seemed determined to ignore her in favour of their preconception that HS2 made Crossrail 2 essential.

Then, when getting excited about the impact of fares on choice of route, the Committee didn’t realise that sitting in front of it were the very people who could enlighten them, in the form of representatives from Virgin Trains and London Midland. No-one actually thought to ask how the Birmingham business splits between Virgin’s fast expensive trains to Euston and London Midland’s slow cheap ones. The noble Lords instead speculated at length about demand on SouthEastern’s services from Kent, where choice of route depends at least as much on which terminus you can walk to work from as on speed and price.

Lord Carrington then excelled himself by suggesting that HS2 was “just a punt”. Well, welcome to the real world, where judgements have to be made about what people will do in the future, “people” and “the future” being about the least predictable things I can think of. But people with responsibilities, as opposed to Lords who enjoy the luxury of sitting back and pontificating, can’t use that as an excuse for doing nothing in the face of real problems such as HS2 addresses.

For a Committee that couldn’t cope with uncertainty about the future, though, its enthusiasm for the nascent driverless cars was a surprise. What relevance exactly do they think driverless cars have to long-distance rail demand? Do they really think that just because people wouldn’t have to steer down the M1, they are willingly going to suffer (and thus add to) the congestion on the Edgware Road from the M1 into central London? If driverless cars have any relevance at all, they sound to me like a rather good way of accessing railway stations – such as Meadowhall.

Perhaps the whole affair was typified by Lord May (an Australian, which would presumably upset Frank Dobson MP who likes to run down HS2’s Sir David Higgins on the basis of his nationality). This heavyweight (speciality – theoretical ecology) played to the Twitterati by declaring that he wouldn’t trust HS2 to mow his lawn. Not that he’d interviewed anyone from HS2 at that point, of course, but never let knowledge get in the way of a soundbite.

Not wishing to respond in a similar churlish vein, may I say that I would happily trust Lord May and his colleagues with mowing my lawn – but not with anything to do with economics.

Recent Posts

  • Asian adventure day 17. From Kuala Lumpur into Thailand…
  • Asian adventure day 16. Kuala Lumpur day 10.
  • Asian adventure day 15. Kuala Lumpur day 9.
  • Whatever happened to the anti HS2 campaign?
  • Asian adventure day 14. Kuala Lumpur day 8.

Recent Comments

Dawn Bigland on Asian adventure day 16. Kuala…
Andy on Whatever happened to the anti…
Trisha on Whatever happened to the anti…
Paul Bigland on Whatever happened to the anti…
nigel on Whatever happened to the anti…

Archives

  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • December 2015
  • November 2015
  • October 2015
  • September 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • May 2015
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • June 2013

Categories

  • 'Green' madness
  • 'Think Tanks'
  • 144e
  • 2005 London bombing
  • 2017 General election
  • 3 peaks by rail
  • 3 Peaks by ral
  • 51M
  • 7/7
  • Abandoned railways
  • Abu Dhabi
  • ACoRP
  • Adam Smith Institute
  • Adrian Quine
  • Advertising
  • Air Travel
  • Aircraft
  • Airports
  • Airshows
  • Allan Cook
  • Amsterdam
  • Andrea Leadsom MP
  • Andrew Gilligan
  • Andrew Haylen
  • Andy Burnham MP
  • Anti Hs2 mob
  • AONBs
  • Arambol
  • Architecture
  • Art
  • Australia
  • Bali
  • Bangkok
  • Bank holidays
  • Barrow Hill
  • Belgium
  • Bereavement
  • Berlin
  • Bigotry
  • Birmingham
  • Blists Hill
  • Blue passports
  • Boris Johnson MP
  • Brexit
  • Brighouse
  • Brighton
  • British Railways
  • British Railways (BR)
  • Byline media
  • Calder Valley
  • Canals
  • Carillion
  • Carolyne Culver
  • Censorship
  • Charities
  • Cheryl Gillan MP
  • Cheshire
  • China
  • Chris Packham
  • Claire Perry MP
  • Class 155
  • Class 313
  • Class 314s
  • Class 317
  • Class 320
  • Class 321
  • Class 365
  • Class 455
  • Class 456
  • Class 507
  • Class 508
  • Class 60s
  • Class 91
  • Climate Change
  • Communications
  • Community
  • Community rail
  • Community Rail Network
  • COP26
  • Corbynwatch
  • Coronavirus
  • Covid 19
  • CP5
  • Crap journalism
  • Crazy anti Hs2 campaigner of the week
  • Crazy kippers
  • Crewe Hub
  • Crossrail
  • Cuba
  • Cumbria
  • Customs
  • Cyberattacks
  • Cycle India
  • Cycling
  • Dawn
  • Democracy
  • Denmark
  • Derbyshire
  • Desiro City
  • Diary
  • Dispatches
  • Doha
  • Donald Trump
  • Doomed
  • Down memory lane
  • East Midlands Railway franchise
  • East Midlands Trains
  • Easter fairy stories
  • ECML
  • Economic illiteracy
  • Economics
  • election2015
  • Engineering
  • Environment
  • Essex
  • Eurostar
  • Euston
  • Extinction Rebellion
  • Fake News
  • Festivals
  • Film and TV
  • Flooding
  • Flora and Fauna
  • Food
  • Food and drink
  • Foot in mouth
  • Gardening
  • GBRf
  • General election
  • General election 2019
  • Georgetown
  • Germany
  • Glasgow
  • Glossop
  • GNGE
  • GNRP
  • Goa
  • Grand Central trains
  • Grant Shapps MP
  • Great Western Railway
  • Greater Anglia franchise
  • Greece
  • Green issues
  • Green madness
  • Green Party
  • Gt Missenden
  • GTR
  • Guido Fawkes
  • GWML
  • GWR franchise
  • Gwyll Jones
  • Halifax
  • Harvil Rd Hs2 protest
  • Harz railway
  • Heathrow 3rd runway
  • High Speed 1
  • High Speed UK
  • History
  • Hitachi
  • Hong Kong
  • House of Lords
  • HS North
  • Hs2
  • Hs2 Bow Group
  • Hs2 petitions
  • Hs2 Phase 2B
  • Hs2 to Crewe
  • Hs2aa
  • HS2Rebellion
  • HSUK
  • Huddersfield
  • Humberside
  • Humour
  • Hurricane Ophelia
  • Hypocrisy
  • I love my job
  • Imperial College London
  • India
  • Indonesia
  • Infrarail
  • Innotrans
  • Internet
  • Iolo Williams
  • Ireland
  • Islamophobia
  • Jacob Rees Mogg
  • Jeremy Corbyn
  • Jeremy Corbyn MP
  • Jo Johnson MP
  • Joe Rukin
  • John McDonnell MP
  • John Poyntz
  • Johnathan Bartley
  • Journalism
  • Kent
  • Kuala Lumpur
  • Labour election
  • Lancashire
  • Laos
  • Law and order
  • Lazy journalism
  • Leicestershire
  • Liam Halligan
  • libel
  • Lilian Greenwood MP
  • Liverpool
  • LNER
  • Local elections
  • Local elections 2018
  • Lockdown
  • London
  • Lord Berkeley
  • LRT
  • M62 motorway
  • Major Projects Authority
  • Malaysia
  • Manchester
  • Manchester Airport
  • Manchester Victoria
  • MAPA
  • Mark Keir
  • Marketing
  • Martin Tett
  • Melton Mowbray
  • Memory Lane
  • Merseyside
  • Michael Dugher MP
  • Michael Fabricant MP
  • Mid Cheshire against Hs2
  • Miscellany
  • Modern Railways
  • Monorails
  • Music
  • Musings
  • Mytholmroyd
  • Natalie Bennett
  • National Rail Awards
  • National Trust
  • Nepal
  • Network Rail
  • Never a dull life
  • New Economics Foundation
  • New trains
  • New Year
  • New York
  • New Zealand
  • NHS
  • Nigel Farage
  • Norfolk
  • Norland scarecrow festival
  • Northern Powerhouse
  • Northern Rail
  • Nostalgia
  • Nottingham
  • Obituaries
  • Old Oak Common
  • ORR
  • Ossett
  • Our cat, Jet
  • Oxfordshire
  • Pacers
  • Paris terror attack
  • Parliament
  • Pasenger Growth
  • Patrick McLouglin MP
  • Penny Gaines
  • Peter Jones
  • Peterborough
  • Photography
  • Photojournalism
  • Picture of the day
  • Poetry
  • Politics
  • Porterbrook
  • PR nightmares
  • Protest
  • Public Accounts Ctte
  • Pubs
  • rail ale
  • Rail electrification
  • Rail fares
  • Rail Investment
  • Rail Live 2021
  • Rail Live 2022
  • RAIL magazine
  • Rail Moderinsation
  • Rail PR
  • Railfreight
  • Railstaff awards
  • Railtex
  • Railway Benefit Fund (RBF)
  • Railways
  • Rant
  • Religion
  • RFEM
  • Richard Wellings
  • Ride India
  • Road accidents
  • Rolling blogs
  • ROSCOs
  • Royal Mail
  • Royal Wedding 2018
  • RSPB
  • Rugby Observer
  • Rushbearing
  • SAIP
  • Scores on the doors
  • Scotland
  • Scotrail
  • Sheffield
  • Shrewsbury
  • Shropshire
  • Siemens
  • Signalling
  • Silly season
  • Simon Heffer
  • Simon Jenkins
  • Singapore
  • Sleeper trains
  • Snail mail
  • Social media
  • South West Trains
  • Southport
  • Sowerby Bridge
  • Spectator magazine
  • Sri Lanka
  • St Pancras station
  • Stafford
  • Stamford
  • Station buffets
  • StopHs2
  • Surrey
  • Talgo
  • Teresa May
  • Terrorism
  • Tesla
  • Thailand
  • Thameslink
  • The 'Beast from the East'
  • The BBC
  • The Big 6
  • The Daily Express
  • The end of the line
  • The fog
  • The Grauniad
  • The Great Central railway
  • The Green Party
  • The Independent
  • The Moorcock Inn
  • The Piece Hall
  • The Railway Children
  • The Rodelblitz
  • The USA
  • The Woodland Trust
  • Tilford
  • Tony Allen
  • Torquay
  • Tourism
  • TPE
  • Traffic congestion
  • Trams
  • Trans-Pennine electrification
  • Transport
  • Transport for Wales (TfW)
  • Travel
  • Twilight years
  • Twitter
  • Twitter (and how not to use it)
  • UK
  • UK steel industry
  • UKIP
  • Uncategorized
  • Vandalism
  • Victoria Prentis MP
  • Virgin Trains
  • Virgin West Coast
  • Vivarail
  • Wales
  • Walking
  • Warwickshire
  • WCML
  • Weather
  • West Yorkshire
  • Wigan
  • Wildlife Trusts
  • Worcester
  • Work
  • World War 1
  • World War Two
  • Yorkshire
  • YorkshireStopHs2

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.com

Blog at WordPress.com.

  • Follow Following
    • Paul Bigland
    • Join 400 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Paul Bigland
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar